3 mins

A much improved newsletter sign up flow


When working with email lists a lot of people make the mistake of thinking all they’ve got to do is collect email addresses' and that's job done. If it was that simple the average newsletter open rate wouldn't be just 21%.

Revue knows a thing or two about sending emails so I thought I’d have a look at their flow once you sign up to a newsletter.

Confirmation Email

Firstly they send a confirmation email and remind you to check your inbox.

Revue Confirmation Email

The beauty of the confirmation email is that it forces the customer to track down your initial email, preventing it from getting left behind in spam.

Add to Address Book

Their second step is asking to be added to their recipients' address book.

Revue Address Book

As spam filters continue to tighten, this really is the only foolproof way of guaranteeing your email gets delivered to your recipients' primary inbox. And as you'll see later on it does make a big difference to open rates.

Any smaller business or personal newsletter can play the “honest, well meaning, underdog” card and get away with asking to be “added to your contacts list”. In contrast, big corps daren't make this request and so their emails tend to push up daises in the Promotion Tab cemetery.

Promotions Tab Cemetery

My version

Inspired by Revue’s example I came up with my own flow for Marketing Examples. It's a pretty similar two step process:

1. Confirmation email on sign-up. Prompt to check spam prevents initial email getting lost.

Marketing Examples email signup

2. The confirmation email nicely asks the recipient to whitelist.

Marketing Examples welcome email

Although these instructions aren't the “coolest”, getting emails read is my priority.

Does it work?

Well, the first batch of people who signed up to the Marketing Examples newsletter never got an initial email. One week later I added the new welcome flow and more people joined. So I could split my email list into two different segments.

I found that 73% of those who received my welcome email opened my latest email newsletter, compared to just 48% of those who never got my initial email.

So yes, a good welcome flow and asking to whitelist does seem to make a big difference to open rates.

Marketing Examples: Before / After Welcome Email
cegfilterplus copy 6
cegfilterplus copy 5
Group 3 Copy 2 1
Group 3 Copy 3
CopywritingLanding Page
#1 Marketing Newsletter”
Read by 130k
Hey, I'm Harry. Every Monday I share:
3 short examples
2 copywriting tips
1 favourite tweet
Marketers voted it the “#1 marketing newsletter”. 130k people enjoy it.
Try it
Dave Gerhadt
“My favourite newsletter on the web”
Dave Gerhadt
“The newsletter is so f***ing great!”
Dave Gerhadt
“Better than my marketing degree
Dave Gerhadt
“🦄🦄🦄 — Nuff said
Dave Gerhadt
“The best thing is it works
Dave Gerhadt
“How is this still free?
Dave Gerhadt
“A genius that actually gives a sh*t
Anne-Laure Le-Cnuff
“I have no regrets
Dave Gerhadt
Best newsletter I'm subbed to”
Dave Gerhadt
“You ALWAYS find something useful”
Dave Gerhadt
“No fluff marketing. Works right now
Dave Gerhadt
“Shit you actually want in your inbox”
Dave Gerhadt
“Sadly, there's only one Harry Dry”
Anne-Laure Le-Cnuff
“Most wisdom per newsletter of all time
Dave Gerhadt
“One of the best marketers I know”
Dave Gerhadt
One of the best things on the web”
Dave Gerhadt
“I can feel my brain getting smarter
Anne-Laure Le-Cnuff
“The Sir Alex Ferguson of marketing”
Dave Gerhadt
“I haven't read a bad one yet”
Dave Gerhadt
I wanna be Harry when I grow up”
Dave Gerhadt
Gems everywhere
Dave Gerhadt
Dangerous in the wrong hands”
Anne-Laure Le-Cnuff
“If you don’t read Marketing Examples you aren’t really a marketer
Dave Gerhadt
“I literally can't wait for new issues”
Dave Gerhadt
“Multiple notifications so I never miss it
Dave Gerhadt
“The only newsletter I share with every person that joins my team”